A few days ago one of my friends posted a quote that, I think, succinctly describes the root problem behind many problems today. It was retweeted from some Buddhist meditation account, and it said: We’re sometimes caught in the assumption that we are actually ‘this person’ with these problems.
This tweet is a very good tweet: if you’re a Buddhist. It falls right in line behind your theology of the permanent self, or rebirth, or karma, or the Noble Eightfold Path (essentially, the way to the cessation of suffering). If you believe this, of course you’re not actually this person with these problems. You’re merely part of the universe skipping merrily along at some point on the Noble Eightfold Path. So like I said, makes sense if you’re a Buddhist. Good for you. But it doesn’t change the fact that it’s false, and that it’s doubly harmful if you still believe that and aren’t Buddhist.
Even evangelicals, from the progressive to the conservative, tap into this thought in some manner. While the emergent progressive might actually fully question absolute truth & reality in general, even the fundamental conservative pulls some strands of thought from this detachment of reality. They spiritualize nearly everything, building for themselves an alternate spiritual reality in which things really matter.
I’m going to venture deeper into this and try to explain myself.
It’s not inherently bad that folks attempt to spiritualize everything that happens or exists. What tends to become problematic is when this spiritual side of things is fractured from the material; it becomes subconsciously Gnostic even though they might consciously reject Gnosticism. Of course material things aren’t evil, they say, but then they might go on to prove that they find greater righteousness in various forms of pietism or legalistic living.
It swiftly morphs into extrabiblical judgmentalism. You bought a shirt made in China under poor labor conditions, they might say, and therefore you’ve now been knocked down a rung on the ladder of goodness. You are eating organic beef just like God made it, they say, and you go up a rung. You listen to choral gospel chants. Plus one! You’re a farmer. Plus one! You read only enriching theology books. Plus one! You have like a dozen children. Plus one! You pull important holy messages from everything you read & watch. Plus one!
It’s not that these things can’t be spiritual. But what’s bad is the disconnect. What’s bad is taking all of the behaviors of life and creating a false alternate spiritual reality out of them: merely jogging is not enough, so let’s praise jog for glory. Merely eating well is not enough, so let’s eat well because it makes us holier.
What’s the difference? It should all be the same thing. If you’re truly looking for the proper way to live life, then you mix it all in together. Jogging is already good in and of itself. Watching The Office is already good in and of itself, even without drawing important life lessons from each episode. There’s no need to spiritualize everyday behaviors, because we were already meant to do them and to do them well.
That is why I would propose that it is good to just go drive around, not because you’re meditating while you do it or because you’re driving it for God’s glory or because you’re taking a crate of organic asparagus to the homeless shelter…but because it’s just good to drive around in a car. Sometimes it can just be good to go out and shoot a few hundred rounds of ammo. Or to pull a shot of espresso. Or to crochet a doily. Or to drink a glass of wine. Or to rake some leaves. Just for the plain darn heck of it!
Assigning spiritual brownie points to so many actions doesn’t make you holier. If anything it can fracture your worldview and misalign your priorities and mix up your judgments, until even an evangelical begins to regard the spiritual and physical worlds in the same manner that the Buddhist does, which is really not that different than flat-out Gnosticism. Bills? They don’t matter. They’re merely physical. I’m living for heaven. God will take care of me.
The sad part is, it’s difficult these days to get reincarnated. You’ve only got one chance, and that’s a very real chance on a very real Earth, and that’s why you have to pay bills.